Explore MySmileEd
Emergency!
Where to look first when a tooth gets hurt or something urgent happens.
Ask Cozy
What would you like to learn?
TRY ASKING
Browse by topic
When a baby tooth is lost earlier than it would have gone naturally, the neighbouring teeth can drift into the gap. A space maintainer is a small appliance fitted to hold that space open until the permanent tooth arrives. This page explains what one is, what it is for, the kinds that exist, and how long they last — including what the AAPD says about how well they work, which is more honest than you might expect.
A small appliance that sits in the gap left by a baby tooth and stops the teeth on either side moving into it. Some are cemented in and stay put; some can be taken out. They are not braces — they do not move teeth or correct anything. Their whole job is to keep things where they already are.
The AAPD states the goal plainly: to prevent loss of arch length, width and perimeter by maintaining the relative position of the existing teeth. And it sets an endpoint — the appliance should function until the permanent tooth has erupted into the correct position.
Think of it like saving someone’s seat. A grown-up tooth is on its way, but it is not ready yet — so this little helper sits in the gap and keeps the space free until the new tooth is ready to come in.
This is the only thing in Cavity Corner that is not a treatment for a tooth. It is a response to a tooth being gone. That is why it usually follows an extraction — and why the decision about it is made separately, after the tooth has come out, rather than at the same time.
A baby tooth is not only for chewing. It is also holding a place for the permanent tooth forming in the bone beneath it. Lose it early and that place can start to close up.
That third point is easy to miss and worth holding on to: the best space maintainer is the child’s own tooth, kept in good shape. An appliance is what follows when that is no longer possible.
The AAPD groups them three ways, by whether they are fixed in place and how much of the mouth they span. You may hear a specific name — band and loop, distal shoe, lingual holding arch, Nance appliance, transpalatal arch — and each belongs to one of these three families. Which suits a particular gap is your dentist’s judgement.
Cemented in and spanning a single gap. The AAPD lists band and loop, crown and loop, and distal shoe in this group. Where a crown is used as the anchor, that is the same kind of crown described on the Crowns page.
Cemented in and running from one side of the mouth to the other, holding several teeth in position at once. The AAPD lists the lower lingual holding arch, the Nance appliance and the transpalatal arch here.
Taken in and out rather than cemented. The AAPD lists partial dentures and Hawley-type appliances. These depend on being worn, which the AAPD notes is part of a wider point about space maintainers needing ongoing cooperation.
The AAPD is direct about the practicalities, and they are not what most families expect. An appliance fitted today is unlikely to be the last word.
The AAPD’s wording is careful. It says it is prudent to consider space maintenance when primary teeth are lost prematurely, and that the use of space maintainers to reduce the prevalence and severity of malocclusion should be considered. Considered — not automatically done. It then lists ten things that bear on it, among them which tooth was lost, how long ago, the child’s dental age, how far the permanent successor has developed and how much bone covers it, the child’s oral hygiene, and their ability to cope with an appliance.
And then there is this, which the AAPD states in the same section and which most sources leave out: consensus or evidence regarding the effectiveness of space maintainers in preventing or reducing the severity of malocclusion is lacking. It also notes that the literature on using them for particular teeth consists of expert opinion, case reports and appliance design. That does not mean they do not work, and it is not a reason to decline one. It means the decision rests more on clinical judgement than on settled evidence — which is worth knowing when you are weighing it up.
A space maintainer has been suggested and I want to understand it. Ask which type, why that one, roughly how long it is expected to stay in, what happens if it comes loose, and what would happen if you decided against it. All of those are reasonable questions and none of them are a challenge to your dentist’s judgement. There is a list of questions to ask a dentist in the For Parents section. Nothing here is a second opinion, and none of it is based on your child’s teeth.
The honest answer is that the evidence is not settled. The AAPD states that premature loss of a primary tooth has the potential to cause loss of space, but that consensus or evidence regarding the effectiveness of space maintainers in preventing or reducing the severity of malocclusion is lacking. It still says their use should be considered. Both things are true at once: the reasoning is sound, the trials confirming the outcome have not been done. Your dentist is making a judgement, and it is reasonable to ask them to explain it.
In principle, until the permanent tooth arrives — the AAPD states the appliance should function until the permanent tooth has erupted into the correct position. In practice it may not be the same appliance throughout: the AAPD cites mean survival times under two years for most types, and notes that adjustment or a new appliance may be necessary as a child grows.
Contact your dentist. It is common rather than alarming — the AAPD reports decementation or loss of cement as the most frequent reason space maintainers fail, and says clinicians should prepare for repair, recementation or replacement. A loose or missing appliance is not doing its job, so it is worth ringing rather than waiting for the next routine visit.
It can be. Plaque accumulation and decay both appear on the AAPD’s list of adverse effects associated with space maintainers, alongside soft tissue impingement and unwanted tooth movement. That is a reason to ask your dentist how to clean around the appliance specifically, and a reason the routine on Brushing matters more rather than less while one is fitted.
No. Braces move teeth deliberately; a space maintainer holds the existing teeth where they are. The AAPD describes the goal as preventing loss of arch length, width and perimeter by maintaining the relative position of the teeth already present. They can look similar, especially the fixed ones that span the arch, which is why the two get confused. If orthodontic treatment is a separate question for your child, Orthodontic referrals covers it.
Every clinical statement on this page comes from the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry documents below, including the statement that evidence on effectiveness is lacking.
This website is for education only and does not replace care from your dentist, physician, or emergency services.